Zhang Yimou Releases New Film to “Battle” with Hollywood

Zhang Yimou

Zhang Yimou

Film Director Battles For Soul of Chinese Cinema” is the provocative title of an NPR report on Zhang Yimou’s new release A Simple Noodle Story (Sanqiang Pai’an Jingqi). Compared with the director’s early national allegories (Raise the Red Lantern; To Live) which made his name as an international arthouse auteur, the new comedy-murder movie is distinctly apolitical.

A radical remake of the Coen brothers’ 1984 neo-noir Blood Simple, Zhang’s latest work transplants the action from a Texas bar to a remote noodle shop in ancient China, and adds on to the crime thriller “a slapstick comedy with song-and-dance numbers revolving around noodle-making.” In an interview with NPR, Zhang does not deny the “commercial factors” behind his new experiment: he intends to make a “New Year film” (the Chinese equivalent of an American holiday season film) and to change his focus from the international to the domestic market.

Zhang is equally straightforward about his ambition behind the commercial turn, which the article dubs as his “battle with Hollywood for the soul of Chinese cinema.” According to the director:

Young people are the key. If they lose their interest in domestic movies, we will be in big trouble. The China’s film market will be occupied by foreigners. Hong Kong, Taiwan and Korea are examples of this. The mainland is our last battlefield.

Behind this patriotism, the article also notes the director’s changed stature in China’s national imagination. The hugely popular successes in the spectacular Olympic opening ceremony in 2008 and the military parade marking China’s 60th anniversary in 2009 made him a national cultural hero, but also raised doubts “overseas” about whether Zhang had became Beijing’s “artist in residence.”

Zhang denies losing independence, arguing that censorship limits all Chinese directors equally, but his latest film has been panned after its premiere in China on Dec. 11. Half of those answering one online survey at a popular website, Sina.com, thought it was “terrible” or “worse than expected.” For China’s arguably most famous director, the leap between the political and the commercial, or the merging of the two, is not an easy one.

Tags: , , , , ,

  • http://yolearnchinese.com Waiguoguizi

    Has Mr Zhang considered making better movies, instead of criticizing the Chinese youth for watching Western movies?

    Look at Chinese movies, there are only 5 types of Chinese movie.
    Love story (with a kiss on the cheek as the highlight), Comedy (which is more embarrassing than funny), Kung Fu movies, Ancient heroic movies and Movies about the war (bad Japanese guys, good Chinese guys)

    Nothing else at all. It just repeats all the time. No wonder foreign movies are far more popular.

  • Lu Chen

    Thank you for your very interesting comment! Despite all the spotlights he continues to enjoy, I don’t think Zhang Yimou still represents the frontier of Chinese cinema ever since at least Hero (2002), if not Shanghai Triad (1995). Zhang’s current status as “national cultural hero” domestically and “China’s most famous director” abroad actually reflects some serious limitations in the Chinese film system today. Many articles we published or reported on in this blog, especially those by Shelly Kraicer and Chris Berry, find Chinese cinema in its most lively in the independent productions by digital-generation filmmakers, which often cover refreshingly new topics of earnest social concern. (For instance, the last Chinese film I saw and quite admired, “Fujian Blue” (Jin bi hui huang, dir. Weng Shuoming, Dragons and Tigers Award 2007) is an adrift youth story against the background of the rampant smuggling and the resulting imbalanced development in the coastal Fujian Province.) Although most of these films enjoy a “shadowy” presence in China and haven’t attracted the attention from mainstream western media like NPR, this blog and our company dGenerate Films are working on changing the landscape.